Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Wednesday, 20th August 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the The Scotsman site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Day the giants took a sound beating



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 03 July 2008
IT may go down in history as The Week the Lights Went Out. Plunging mortgage lending, crumbling business confidence, soaring oil and inflation, serial collapses in the housebuilding sector and a quarter of the stock market value of the high street icon Marks & Spencer wiped out in a trice: the news flow has been dire.
Taylor Wimpey, one of the biggest names in housebuilding, saw its shares crash 41 per cent yesterday on news that a £500 million re-financing deal with its banks had fallen through, putting it in breach of its banking covenants.

Other top-name builders, such as Persimmon, have also been struck down as the mortgage famine and slump in confidence deepen the crisis in the building sector. Shares in Barratt have collapsed over 95 per cent.

Confidence – that magical lubricant that drives every business and every spending decision – is on the skids.

Yesterday Sir Stewart Rose, the M&S chairman, warned of "stormy times ahead". Charles Bean, the deputy Governor of the Bank of England, said yesterday that we face a year or more of lower living standards as a result of the soaring world oil price.

Problems have been building for months. And they form part of a bigger and altogether more troubling picture of what has gone wrong in the global economy and what lies in store.

The scale of the collapse in the value of bank credit paper has intensified as soaring oil has put paid to the prospect of an economic recovery powered by further cuts in interest rates.

Sales of "big ticket" items are already tumbling as household confidence has slumped to within a whisker of its record low in March 1990 – just ahead of the plunge into a deep recession.

For many, the combination of appalling economic data but apparent "business as normal" is creating an increasingly unreal, spooky atmosphere in the high streets and shopping centres.

Shares are crashing and the confidence indicators look terrible. The sky is filling with black smoke. But where's the fire? House prices are falling – but with some areas less severely hit than others.

For homeowners insisting that the credit crunch has not really hit in their areas, it is like dining at a restaurant while the noise of a violent demolition next door starts to intrude. The floor vibrates and dust starts to fall from the ceiling. What's the problem behind that wall? Why is the noise getting louder?

How much "louder" it will get depends on whether we are in a conventional business cycle or a super cycle – an epochal de-leveraging that could unleash the most savage recession since the Second World War.

Both the Bank for International Settlements and the International Monetary Fund have warned in the past week that the global economy is at a "tipping point". Both used this worrying expression in their recent assessments of the global economic outlook. In its annual report, the BIS says the financial market turmoil is "without precedent in the post-war world".

It adds: "With a significant risk of recession in the US, compounded by sharply rising inflation in many countries, fears are growing that the global economy might be at some kind of tipping point. These fears are not groundless."

So what's happening? The credit crunch that struck last autumn has triggered a massive de-leveraging through the Western world's financial system, creating the equivalent of a credit black hole. The BIS is clear as to the cause of this crisis. In stark and outspoken language, it declares "loans of increasingly poor quality have been made and then sold to the gullible and greedy, the latter often relying on leverage and short-term funding to further increase their profits".

The credit contraction, combined with soaring oil and rising inflation, is now forcing a ferocious slowdown across the world's major economies.

We are not alone. But with the government facing a shortfall in revenues and no slack for tax cuts, and the Bank of England forced to keep interest rates up to counter inflation, it feels as if we have been left on our own.

Is there an upside, and what is it? So far employment has held up well. Even if, as the OECD warns, unemployment rises by 100,000 we are well short of the 2.8 million total reached in 1993.

Second, a savings recovery will boost bank and building society deposits, making more money available for mortgages in due course. And by 2010 America's economy should be past the worst. It is bad news for now. But the cycle will turn.

Household woes to continue as oil prices surge

Lindsay McIntosh


LIVING standards will remain low for at least a year as a result of soaring world oil prices, the new deputy Governor of the Bank of England warned yesterday.

Charlie Bean's dire prediction came as the retail sector reeled from Marks & Spencer's profits warning and share-price plunge, and a leading housebuilder saw its own shares collapse as it axed hundreds of jobs amid a "significant downturn" in business.

Taylor Wimpey is facing an uncertain future after shareholders refused to back a £500 million emergency cash-raising plan – sending shockwaves and panic throughout the construction sector.

Mr Bean, formerly the Bank's chief economist, said that oil prices – already at a record high – might continue to rise for another two years.

Giving evidence to the Commons Treasury Committee, he warned that there was a danger of a pay-price spiral developing if workers tried to compensate by calling for higher-wage settlements. He said: "It certainly poses a significant challenge. There is no doubt about that.

"It may be a relatively unlikely event, but it could be particularly unfortunate if it happened, if households and businesses start losing faith in the idea that inflation will stay low – round about the target – they start building it into their pay and prices and inflation becomes much more embedded into the system."

Echoing recent warnings by the BoE Governor, Mervyn King, and Alistair Darling, the Chancellor, Mr Bean said there was little the Bank or the government could do to prevent the fall-off in living standards.

"It is determined by global factors. As a nation, it means that our living standards will be lower than they would otherwise be," he said.

He said the recent pick-up in inflation should be temporary, provided pay pressures remained subdued and oil prices did not continue to rise inexorably – although he admitted that was "open to debate".

"I don't think one can discount the possibility that oil prices will continue to rise for a while," he said. "I think, in the longer term, there are good arguments for expecting them to come back because there are alternative sources of supply."

Earlier, the chairman designate of the Financial Services Authority, Lord Turner of Ecchinswell, rejected claims that the rise in oil prices was being driven by speculators.

"There is no large accumulation of evidence, I would have thought, that speculation is playing a major role," he told the committee.

He acknowledged, however, that UK financial markets were "not totally clean" and said that the City watchdog needed to take a tougher approach to tackling market abuses.

Meanwhile, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development said that the UK was facing a 100,000 rise in unemployment over the coming two years.

It said joblessness would rise from 5.4 per cent of the workforce in 2007 to 5.8 per cent in 2009, with the total out of work reaching 1.8 million.

Consumers starting to cut back
M&S


THE high street favourite's plummeting share price adds weight to mounting concerns over the resilience of the consumer sector to weather the economic storm. Spending figures in the early period of the year surprised analysts with their strength but did little to alleviate overriding worries consumers were reining in spending. The profits warning announced by M&S has provided them with unwanted proof their fears were well-founded. Costs of basics such as food and utilities are rising, forcing consumers to cut back on non-essentials. It is likely that customers are switching from recognised or luxury products to own-name or budget brands. This is certainly the case for food, according to analysts.

Waking up and smelling the coffee
STARBUCKS


WHEN cash-strapped consumers are looking for ways to tighten their belts, the £3 morning latte is an obvious casualty. The fall in demand for luxury goods is likely to be a major factor in ubiquitous coffee house Starbucks' plans to close hundreds of its stores across the US. The firm has doubled in size since 2004 and this massive expansion – set against the disastrous US economy – would appear to have hastened its downfall. The closure of 600 stores will see seven per cent of the firm's workforce redundant. American analysts said yesterday that the chain was a victim of its own success – and claimed investors would react positively to the cuts as evidence it was getting its house in order.

Cracks begin to show in construction
TAYLOR WIMPEY


FALLING UK house prices have delivered a major body blow to the country's biggest housebuilder. Taylor Wimpey confirmed it was laying off 900 jobs to cope with the downturn. The firm – which was formed from the merger of George Wimpey and Taylor Woodrow last summer – said its house completions fell by a third in the first six months this year, and that it was not expecting any recovery "in the short-term". It said it was closing 13 regional offices and reducing staffing levels after suffering a "sharp" decline in reservations since April. Taylor Wimpey – which had been trying to raise a reported £500 million to help shore up its finances – said it was concentrating on reducing costs and cutting the prices of built homes.

INFLATION

Both the consumer price index and retail price index have been moving sharply upwards in the last year and are likely to continue to do so in the short-term. This May, CPI hit 3.3, its highest since 1992, and RPI was at 4.3, its highest June 2007.

If prices go up and incomes remain constant, living standards are affected. If higher wages are then demanded to maintain purchasing power, this leads to further inflation.


OIL

The price of oil has significant knock-on effects across the economy and it has been spiralling to more than $140 a barrel. The price hike filters down through numerous markets to impact directly upon consumers' budgets.

It affects those who are paying more to fill up their petrol tanks and those who have utility bills to pay. And it also puts up the cost of doing business. Road hauliers pay more for their fuel, and the resultant higher costs to transport goods are passed on.

BUILDING

The Construction Purchasing Managers' Index plummeted to a new low in June, contracting for four successive months and falling at the fastest rate since the measure was taken.

Although the sector only accounts for about six per cent of UK output, the sharpness of its decline makes it significant.

MORTGAGE APPROVALS

The latest figures for mortgage approvals show they dropped from almost 35,000 in April to less than 30,000 in May – and a decline in mortgage approvals signifies a weak housing market.

This means there are potentially a lot more sellers than buyers and prices are likely to fall – substantially. Analysts argue that a gradual fall is no bad thing but a sharp correction will have knock-on effects for the rest of the economy.

HOUSEHOLD SAVINGS

The household savings ratio is currently at its lowest point since 1959. This means people are living beyond their means. At face value, consumer spending was quite robust in the first quarter of the year, but disposable income fell – so people were financing their spending by cutting back on their savings or even dipping into them. Over the long term, that is not sustainable and people will have to rein in their spending – bad news for the economy.


MANUFACTURING

The Purchasing Managers' Index shows the UK sector has hit its lowest point since the events of 9/11, indicating it is heading for a recession. Output, new orders, work backlogs and employment all fell in June. Manufacturing is a smaller part of the economy than it used to be, but any downturn of this nature is still a bad sign.


CONSUMER CONFIDENCE

Soaring household bills and fears of a looming interest rate hike last month drove consumer confidence to its lowest level since Britain was last facing recession 18 years ago. There is not always a direct link between spending and consumer confidence, so there may be a couple of months when confidence drops but spending remains high.


The full article contains 2144 words and appears in The Scotsman newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

 
1

Evolution in action,

St Andrews 03/07/2008 00:09:42
Time to put on the Zaphod Beeblebrox sunglasses.
2

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 03/07/2008 00:30:04

The 'Greed', could not continue!

'Greed' affects others, that will be the downfall of the Giants!
3

Paula,

03/07/2008 01:06:36
Wait, the bank's chief economist is Mr. Bean?

Suddenly the reasons for the credit crunch become clear.

4

Scullion,

Canada 03/07/2008 01:37:33
What is it with economists and graphs?
The only reason I passed micro and macroeconomics was drawing a graph with so many lines on it during the final that no one could tell that I hadn't a clue-which is about all most professional economists have too. They can tell you why something happened but are brutal at trying to predict what is going to happen despite their graphs.
5

Uilleam Mor,

03/07/2008 02:23:23
Des Browne MP ( Labour) says we have never had it so good!

So did his pal Tom Harris MP (Labour) some two weeks ago.

Must be true and I must be mistaken.

What say you Prudence Brown.
6

bring them on,

03/07/2008 02:37:35
Not a good time to be in debt.

Spend only what you make....the worst has yet to come.
7

W Smith,

Middle East 03/07/2008 03:28:33
Maybe the editor of The Scotsman can help me out here.

According to The Scotsman's previous articles america's economic down turn is George Bush's fault.

So Mr Editor, which party is to blame for the UK's economic downturn?

LIb Dems?
8

Phil C,

03/07/2008 06:58:35
Just imagine if Brown had not been so "prudent"!
9

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 03/07/2008 07:19:03
GRUNCH of giants?

It was only last week or the week before that Mr Jamieson was telling us, we'd never had it so good. Now business confidence has dropped like Gretna Green. I don't have a degree in J & J (journalism and jargon) but here seem worrying things:

If banks can't lend money to farmers, then they can't grow food. Nor can fishermen fish. As no UK government has ever printed money - they have to borrow it from banks (who create it now electronically our of nothing), the UK goes out of business. Look on the bright side! Though I'd expect it'd get a crisis loan for a puckle years since the bankers need taxpayers to pay the interest and their CEOs. Do we see Charlie Bean-Counter having to plant his own potatoes, put the BMW on blocks and get the bus to work during the 2 years of austerity?

Things go in cycles, though to aerodynamicists it looks like a tail spin.
10

FISHWICK,

berwick upon tweed 03/07/2008 07:52:43
THERE IS PLENTY OF OIL IN THE WORLD - GREENLAND, ANTARCTICA [WHAT WAS THE FALKLANDS WAR ABOUT IF IT WASN'T OIL?] BUT IT'S PRICE NEEDS TO RISE TO ACCESS IT. THIS WILL ALSO STIMULATE THE DEVELOPMENT OF ALTERNATIVE MEANS OF POWERING TRANSPORT AND ALSO THE QUESTIONING OF THE NEED FOR SOME HUMAN MOVEMENTS - MORE WORK FROM HOME. IT IS CRAZY FOR MILLIONS OF PEOPLE TO TRAVEL TO WORK IN ORDER TO SIT AT A COMPUTER CONVERSING WITH PEOPLE NOT IN THEIR PHYSICAL PRESENCE.
11

observer9,

Glasgow 03/07/2008 08:02:31
It is well worth noticing that the only people who don't see the the reality of the situation are the government.

The politicians habit of self deception harms the majority of us yet for them the pay, perks and pensions still come. They are either too stupid or are yet again lying to us, a state of affairs that is all too common and will only cause more difficulties.

The truth is and the facts are that if we do not grasp what this situation is and the commensurate effects of globalisation, government inefficiency, after retirement public sector costs and a raft of other spotlighted factors we are in serious serious trouble
12

Jay Kay,

03/07/2008 08:05:34
Other top-name builders, such as Persimmon, oh hahahahahahaha oh god stop it wahahahaha persimmon hahah top builders oh god my sides, there is a sense of humour at the hootsman after all, oh whoaa hahahaha.
13

Jon Bon Jovi,

03/07/2008 08:32:52

Whooah, we're half way there
Livin on a prayer
Take my hand and well make 'it elsewhere'......
Livin on a prayer!!!
14

Upbeat,

03/07/2008 08:38:22
Two years ago in these boards I was pointing out how the British had been foooled by a lax chancellor into spending money they did not have. This magnificent flow of 'money' through the economy, of course, made the chancellor look wise and prudent.Eeverybody was happy...no thought for the future at all. For by spending their earnings years before the money arrived in their pay packets, the whole economy showed steady and remarkable growth. The problem - that borrowed money has to be repaid - was swept from peoples' minds. Money that was borrowed in 2006 and spent on luxuries in 2006 cannot be spent again in 2008.

Simple really.

Now we have houses full of every last gadget, super renovations, skips full of perfectly serviceable bathrooms, TV's , kitchens, doors and windows, trundling off to Land fill. Scrap yards full of cars, washing machines, tools and equipment for which there is no buyer, not because these items are worn out...maybe slightly damaged...but not impossible to repair.

It was obvious that this greed would have a price. That the Labour government can point to the credit problems in the USA as if this is the cause, is a convenient scape-goat for their own blinkered, short sighted mismanagement of the economy and public finances. It has been obvious for many years now where the real blame for permitting huge levels of credit to distort the British economy really lies.

Today those of us who have lived within our means for years, as we were educated to do , are caught up in a storm caused by the unregulated greed of others. We know too well the causes of this ,and have spent years attempting to warn others about what was needed prevent this. This crash has been approaching for years.

Is anyone listening yet ?
15

I just thought....,

Edinburgh 03/07/2008 08:43:50
We keep getting told how brilliant Brown is with the economy, looks to me to me like he’s overspent during the good years and no idea what to do in the bad years. No room for tax cuts to help the economy, must be the corrosion of the iron chancellors legacy now.
16

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

03/07/2008 09:14:16
The last few years have seen the first major widespread BTL phenomenon. If that collapses things could get interesting.

Boom and Bust, always the way. We never learn. Too greedy.
17

Tukhachevsky,

03/07/2008 09:20:01
Yeah Capitalism!
18

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 03/07/2008 09:53:50
Here's a thought While the people cut back why do the government stop spending billions and billions pissing around in the desert with islamist cavemen.

Refuse them access to the Western World. Bring military home. Leave them to kill each other far away.

Another thing we can do is stop pumping billions into India Call centres. Where do people think the money our companies spend thier goes, because it never comes home again.
19

ddmc,

03/07/2008 09:54:12
#6 watch the bankruptcy's rise

#16 with the amount of homes on the market round sighthill, parkhead, forrester park & carrick knowe i reckon the bubble of the BTL has already started to pop

#14 v.true , do you think thats why the US tightened up bankruptcy laws last year ?

#1 has the best suggestion :-D
20

Jock MacTamson 2,

03/07/2008 09:57:02
#16 - Where do you think all the people who are evicted from their 4 bedroom houses are going to live.

Majority of BTL are 1 and 3 bedroom flats. Still massive demand. In declining property market their is an increase in rent and people looking to rent.

What BTL investors will not be able to do is raise money or refinance.

Expect to see rents increase dramatically in next year.

Although if you are lucky you may be one of the few UK citizens who will get a council house!
21

Jock MacTamson 2,

Highlands 03/07/2008 09:57:59
#20 should be 1 and 2 bedroom flats
22

The Genuine Mario Antoinette,

03/07/2008 10:32:41
Maybe you are right Jock. Depends where the BTL is though , normal hotspots like edinburghs meadows areas shouldnt be a problem.

I wouldnt wish reposession on anyone, I'm curious to see how many there will be.

There is a nasty side of me actually enjoying this.

23

Lock,

03/07/2008 12:19:56
I blame the crisis of confidence on the media. If we weren't getting our daily update of how terrible everything was would all this be happening?

Anyhoo, I think what will be shown in history is that there is such a thing as an interest rate that is too low where people stop saving and start borrowing and spending over the odds. But what good is history when you have politicians? Next time round they will do it exactly the same for the sake of a few votes at the next election.
24

Displaced Scot,

UK 03/07/2008 12:30:56
What we are seeing is a correction in economic terms. Some things such as food had become too cheap. People will now learn the value of it again. As for fuel, in real terms it is cheaper to run a car now than it was ten years ago in real terms. Property values had gone crazy and need to cool for a few years, this will evenually bring the first time buyers back on the market.
The buy to let market is a new concept to many people, and many of those involved used it as their pension scheme. The only problem is that it has put more pressure on house prices, keeping the first time buyers out. Once the buy to let market cools things will be more on an even keel.
25

Yok Finney,

Ross-shire 03/07/2008 12:33:32
Since the UK's 1707 inception, our Government NEVER had money to spend. It had to borrow it from the Bank of England. The annual interest then had to be paid by taxation. The people or peasants didn't have money or wages or income to tax. They got enough to eat, and could make their own clothes and houses. So we had levies on commodities at various points in transit. By 1900 most of the peasants had been herded into mills and factories and could also be taxed as they earned (PAYE)

American Presidents from Lincoln to JFK knew how the elite system worked and saw that it was the Govenment's duty, not private banks privilege, to issue the nation's currency and spend it only on essential state infrastructure. National assets could be created (to benefit all productive activity) without debt or interest or more taxation. We're going to do this, they said, so the banksters got them shot!

Labour (once the party of the people) and Libdems now act the same as Tories. Bankers own them all. And the media and the press.
26

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

03/07/2008 12:39:53
Excellent article. It's beginning to dawn that this will be more like the end of the 1930's credit bubble than anything the vast majority of us have seen in our lifetimes.

Rather than continuing to spend beyond our means, folks here need to cut down their lifestyles and save some cash to get through what's coming. By my reckoning we'll see inflation and then deflation. By the time deflation hits, the survivors will have sold assets and paid down their debts. Those still in debt will be crucified by it.
27

Rennie,

Upstate NY 03/07/2008 12:46:26
Drill more gas and oil NOW, mine the coal, keep researching and developing the alternative energy, build the offshore wind or tidal turbines, but don't cripple the economy waiting for technology that we don't have in production yet. They claim one county in Upstate NY has enough natural gas to supply the national demand for 8 years, but the enviromentalists and NIMBYs won't allow it to be drilled, even if it would allow farmers to keep their land, but they want everything built into high priced housing developements or returned to wilderness, everyone assumes food will come from "somewhere else". If you have or can get land to grow a garden, do it now.
28

Can-Scot,

Pickering, Ontario 03/07/2008 14:02:31
I wonder what the folks on the island of Islay think of rising oil prices. Not as daft as you might think. If more people in more countries had tried harder to follow their example, rising oil prices wouldn't mean much.

29

James.com,

03/07/2008 15:32:23
No more Broon and Bust?
30

mcbogtrotter,

maccalifornia 03/07/2008 17:03:27
Well Ive said for along time that this whole economy was based on air money from inflated home prices. At some time it had to colapse you cant buy a half million home on 20.00 per hour. And the refinance scheme put alot of BMW's and boats in alot of driveways
personally I think that the lenders should be made to reset home loan payments to 1/3 of the borrowers income with no negative amortization and leave it alone at some point the homes will either be resold or kept, At this point no one will be paying off their homes anyway so wo cares about how long the loan is just force the lenders to make the repayment affordable and it will work itself out.
31

Dekester,

Canada's westcoast 03/07/2008 17:50:24
Wait till the other shoe drops. That being the public sector, and their wage demands.

The private sector ( Airlines, GM, Starbucks etc.) are all being hammered with unprecedented layoffs, and stock de-valuations. The public sector still needs feeding and is there much coming in the way of lay-offs??
Feeding with what though, as the real taxpayers dry up and cities struggle with a spiralling lower tax base.

Let us get real though, many who anticipated this major correction are delighted and are now in a position to buy cheap bank stocks. Cheaper used cars, homes etc.

What is the old investing axiom. Fear and greed as being the only true motivators. It sure seems apparent at this moment.

All the best, and thanks to all posters.

32

bus user,

edinburgh 03/07/2008 23:32:23
Cut to the chase, Bill, we've been here before, more than once. I know you've read Metal Men, Liar's Poker and FIASCO, as these are the basic material for any financial commentator from the 70s onward. Truth is that regulation for the banks and associated finance organisations is never severe enough to stop the things that are happening now, before, and in the future. I look forward to your own 20/20 hindsight version of the late 2000s.
33

Trade-wind,

USA 04/07/2008 04:07:17
Good posts all! Upbeat #14 you have it about right!
Rennie #27 you to make a great deal of sense. This started when OPEC formed and we sat on our hands!
I have always preached to my 4 kids to stay away from credit cards and to keep debt to a minimum. It was apparent in the early 70's that we were headed here.
We have arrived. 5 years ago I retired and added 3 acres
to the 3 I already owned. I owe nothing on anything and don't have a credit card and never will. Two years ago I told all of my kids to put money aside but not in a bank. We are so very close to a depression that it is not funny. If the wrong thing happens or the right thing happens at the wrong time it will push us into the abyss. The most worrying part is it doesn't have to happen in our country or yours, it can happen anywhere and the result will be the same. World wide depression.
I have enough ground to plant huge gardens and a greenhouse to raise seedlings. (We do that as ageneral rule now). I can raise a hog and a cow and maybe a steer. Chickens and rabbits are also possible as I have three barns in good repair. I have seen this coming and have prepared for it as have my kids. We will be alright. But I worry that when this happens and I think that more likely than not, that we will be faced with having to defend what we have. I truly hope it doesn't happen, but hold on, it will be long and hard.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.